Mining After Mining: Extractive Remains and the “Critical Minerals” Boom in the Andes

Introduction

Our Ford-LASA Special Project brought together scholars from across North America, South America, and Europe to consider the material and symbolic “remains” of mining in the Andes.[1] As an industrial activity and a socioenvironmental practice, mining does not disappear when production ceases. Like other capitalist-colonial projects, it remains on the landscape, in legal and legal-political structures, in social imaginaries and institutions, and even in people’s bodies (Barandiarán 2026, Chari 2024, Gordillo 2014, Nading 2020, Perreault 2013, Stoler 2008). Each member of our team has longstanding research projects that consider the historical remains of mining in countries such as Chile, Colombia, Peru, and Bolivia. Our Ford-LASA Special Project grant allowed us, as a collective, to conduct collaborative fieldwork in northern Chile, present our findings at two LASA International Congresses, develop a themed dossier for publication with the Latin American Research Review, and create a growing research community from which future collaborations will all but certainly emerge.

We developed our original proposal both in response to Latin America’s most recent mining boom and to critically reinterpret the present conjuncture in light of the past. Across Latin America, governments are confronting mounting pressure to expand production of lithium, copper, rare earth elements, nickel, and other minerals considered indispensable for low-carbon technologies (Bringel and Svampa 2024, Dorn 2022, Himley et al. 2025, Riofrancos 2025). Often described as the critical minerals boom, this moment is sometimes portrayed as an unprecedented opportunity to accelerate the global energy transition while generating economic growth for mineral-rich regions like the Andes. As scholars of Andean contexts, we found ourselves unsettled by these framings. We were struck by how discussions of critical minerals often treated the present as a clean break from the past, with little attention to the ways previous extractive cycles continue to shape present-day possibilities and constraints—or to the legacies that today’s mining boom will leave for future generations. It was this shared concern that motivated our collaborative project, which seeks to place contemporary debates over critical minerals within a deeper historical perspective on (how) mining “remains”—with that term understood as both verb and noun (Chari 2024).

Fieldwork and Outputs

Among the various ways we benefited from receiving Ford-LASA Special Project funding, a series of activities carried out by eight members of our group in Chile in late June and early July 2025 proved especially important for consolidating our scholarly collective. These included field visits to sites of historical and contemporary mining operations in Chile’s Antofagasta region. Antofagasta has a long mining history and has witnessed major extractive investment in recent decades, much of which has centered on so-called critical minerals, especially copper and lithium (Jerez et al. 2021, Méndez et al. 2020, Weinberg and Figueroa 2023). Manuel Méndez and Damir Galaz-Mandakovic, both of whom have long-standing research agendas in the region, planned visits to sites that sparked rich conversations about the historical sedimentation of extractive activities. This sedimentation is especially visible in Antofagasta, where the region’s extreme aridity slows the decay of material vestiges from earlier rounds of extraction.

Our itinerary allowed us to trace these layered histories of extraction across a range of sites, infrastructures, and mineral industries. It included visits to ports along Antofagasta’s Pacific coast, where we considered the infrastructural remains of industrial mining, including piers, railways, chemical complexes, desalination plants, thermoelectric facilities, high-voltage transmission lines, pipelines, and roads. At historical and contemporary nitrate mining facilities, we discussed the introduction and later abandonment of materials and technologies imported from Europe and the United States, as well as the lives and deaths of nitrate workers. Visits to current large-scale copper mining operations prompted conversations about their impacts on water availability, air quality, and human health. Finally, at the SQM lithium mine in the Salar de Atacama (Atacama Salt Flat), we toured operations, observed new technologies being tested to enhance production, and considered the infrastructural and socio-environmental implications of lithium mining. More on these field visits can be found in the post authored by one of our participants, Esteban Valle-Riestra Padró, for the University of Manchester’s Global Development Institute Blog.[2]

While in San Pedro de Atacama, an oasis town on the Salar de Atacama, we took the opportunity to hold a workshop dedicated to identifying ideas and themes emerging from our collective fieldwork that could form the basis for future collaborative research and writing. These discussions came to revolve around three dimensions of extractive development—energy systems, physical infrastructures, and extractive toxicities—and how each of these shapes both how mining “remains” and how differently situated people engage mining’s material and symbolic vestiges. During our time in Chile, we further developed these ideas through participation in a seminar at Universidad Mayor in Santiago, entitled “Legados Mineros: Conversando con el Pasado para Entender el Presente y Futuro de la Minería en los Andes.” Four project participants are currently developing a paper for a special issue of The Extractive Industries and Society that addresses these themes via an analysis of technological and energy transformations linked to recent extractive development in Antofagasta.

Our 2025 fieldwork trip to Antofagasta was bookended by project roundtables at two LASA International Congresses: LASA 2025 in San Francisco and LASA 2026 in Paris. The 2025 session, held in hybrid format and organized by Matthew Himley, presented the project's main guidelines. This session featured brief presentations by Heidi Scott, Daniela Mosquera-Camacho, Manuel Méndez, Javiera Madrid-Salazar, and Matthew Himley, with Javiera Madrid-Salazar as chair and Andrea Marston as discussant. At the 2026 conference, three project members—Manuel Méndez, Esteban Valle-Riestra Padró, and Lorena Campuzano Duque—presented their individual research projects. Tania Lucia Ramírez Farias acted as chair, and Reynaldo De los Reyes Patiño was the discussant.

Finally, a central output of our project is a dossier prepared for Latin American Research Review, currently under peer review. Titled "Remainders of Mining Past: Engaging the Material and Symbolic Legacies of Extraction in the Andes," the dossier comprises a collection of research articles and an introductory essay co-written by members of our group. Spanning Chile, Colombia, and Peru, the articles examine how communities, governments, and scientists have engaged with mining's material and symbolic remains across three themes: scientific discourse and mining's past and future; changing relationships to mining waste and its health and environmental effects; and community coexistence with or resistance to mining over time. The introductory essay, in addition to synthesizing the findings of each contribution, provides a brief conceptual discussion of scholarship on the material and immaterial remains left by mining, legacies that continue to shape the present of mining territories.

Critical Extractivisms: Trends and Futures

While our shared research focuses on the historical legacies of mineral extraction, recent political trends across the Americas are reshaping both the future of extractive industries and the conditions under which critical research on extractivism takes place. A notable rightward shift has slowed efforts toward energy transition while further undermining social movements advocating for environmental protection, Indigenous territorial rights, and more equitable models of development. At the same time, demand for critical minerals persists, increasingly framed not in terms of decarbonization but through renewed concerns with resource security, amid intensifying geopolitical competition and shifting trade relationships. In the United States, where many members of our research collective are located, recent industrial policies have framed access to critical minerals as essential to economic competitiveness. For example, President Trump’s efforts to secure this access have included establishing the “Shield of the Americas,” a geopolitical framework that seeks to build trade relationships with conservative Latin American administrations to counter China’s supply-chain dominance.

This rightward political shift has also had direct impacts on us as researchers in the critical social sciences and humanities. In the United States, these impacts have taken the form of funding cuts and restricted immigration status for students, faculty, and visiting scholars. The National Science Foundation (NSF) has cut or canceled more than 1,500 active research grants, targeting those dealing with issues of social inequity and environmental change, as well as those rooted in social and behavioral sciences (Schwabish and Axelrod 2025). The National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH) was threatened with complete elimination, and more than 1,400 previously approved grants were temporarily cancelled. While federal courts restored the grants and Congress preserved NEH funding, the institution’s future is far from guaranteed (Schuessler 2026). Internal research priorities have also shifted at some universities as administrators sought to minimize exposure to federal investigations and funding cuts, and faculty are sometimes encouraged to avoid language related to diversity, environmental justice, gender identity, or colonialism in grant proposals and public-facing research materials (Miller and Rabin 2026). Meanwhile, the Trump administration has significantly tightened regulations for international students, shifting from flexible, long-standing approvals to strict degree completion deadlines, heightened vetting, and targeted visa revocations (DHS 2026). Two participants in our Ford-LASA project were US-based doctoral students originally from Latin America, and uncertainty surrounding their immigration statuses created new roadblocks for their fieldwork and program completion timelines.

This situation is mirrored in much of Latin America. In Chile, for example, the far-right government has revised science policy around ten new “strategic areas,” defined without consulting the scientific community, that will absorb up to 70 percent of postdoctoral research funding. The policy abandons merit-based, discipline-blind adjudication, excludes Humanities and Arts outright, and retains Social Sciences only under labels such as “Human Capital and Productivity” (Laborde 2026). A parallel dismantling is underway in environmental and heritage governance. “Permisología,” or “permitology,” has become a catch-all term that recasts environmental and citizen oversight as bureaucratic friction (Irarrázaval 2025). This rhetoric has translated into an opaque “fast track” strategy for reviewing environmental cases and legislative efforts to weaken environmental and heritage protections. Although the Constitutional Court struck down several provisions weakening environmental oversight, new rules impose a 20-day deadline after which the National Monuments Council loses authority over archaeological finds (Guerra 2026). Together, these changes reveal a coherent rationale: subordinating knowledge, environmental protection, and cultural memory to the calendar of capital investment. Chile’s experience, moreover, echoes a broader regional pattern of far-right anti-intellectualism, from Milei’s Argentina to Bolsonaro’s Brazil, that devalues knowledge and practices that resist subordination to market logic.

In contexts such as these, programs like the Ford-LASA Special Projects provide more than a welcome source of research funding. They help sustain the institutional and intellectual spaces in which critical scholarship can continue, while creating opportunities for collaboration among scholars from different countries, institutions, disciplines, and stages of academic training. Such spaces are especially important at a moment when the conditions for critical research are becoming increasingly precarious across the Americas. By supporting sustained exchange and collective inquiry across national and institutional boundaries, programs like this one help preserve not only particular research agendas, but also the scholarly communities necessary to carry them forward.

Indeed, while our project has generated new insights into how mining “remains” in the Andes, perhaps its most important contribution is the academic collective. Rather than representing the culmination of a research agenda, this collaboration marks the beginning of a longer conversation. As debates over mining continue to intensify across the Americas, we hope this collective will continue to develop new comparative and historically grounded approaches that illuminate not only the legacies of past extractive booms, but also the futures they continue to produce.

Notes

[1] The principal investigators for this Ford-LASA Special Project were Matthew Himley (Illinois State University, USA), Andrea Marston (Rutgers University, USA), Manuel Méndez (Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso, Chile), Damir Galaz-Mandakovic (Universidad de Tarapacá, Chile), and Heidi Scott (University of Massachusetts Amherst, USA). Additional participants included Pablo Jaramillo (Universidad de los Andes, Colombia), Javiera Madrid-Salazar (Rutgers University, USA), Daniela Mosquera-Camacho (Rutgers University, USA), Esteban Valle-Riestra Padró (University of Manchester, UK), Lorena Campuzano Duque (Université de Montréal, Canada), and Zaraí Toledo (Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú).

[2] See Esteban Valle-Riestra Padró, “Silence, Dust and Oblivion: Reflections on Extractive Legacies from the Atacama Desert,” Global Development Institute, The University of Manchester, August 12, 2025, https://blog.gdi.manchester.ac.uk/silence-dust-and-oblivion-reflections-on-extractive-legacies-from-the-atacama-desert/.

References

Barandiarán, Javiera. 2026. Living Minerals: Nature, Trade, and Power in the Race for Lithium. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Bringel, Breno, and Maristella Svampa. 2024. “Energy Transition and the New Shape of Green Colonialism: The Emergence of the Decarbonisation Consensus.” In Dependency Theories in Latin America, edited by André Magnelli, Felipe Maia, and Paulo Henrique Martins, 242-258. New York: Routledge.

Chari, Sharad. 2024. Apartheid Remains. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

Department of Homeland Security. 2026. “Trump Administration Issues Final Rule to End Foreign Student Visa Abuse.” Department of Homeland Security, July 16. https://www.dhs.gov/news/2026/07/16/trump-administration-issues-final-rule-end-foreign-student-visa-abuse

Dorn, Felix Malte. 2022. “Green Colonialism in Latin America? Towards a New Research Agenda for the Global Energy Transition.” European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies/Revista Europea de Estudios Latinoamericanos y Del Caribe, no. 114: 137-146.

Gordillo, Gastón R. 2014. Rubble: The Afterlife of Destruction. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

Guerra, Felipe. 2026. “Patrimonio arqueológico bajo amenaza por megarreforma: la falsa eficiencia de destruir antes de conocer.” CIPER, July 10. https://www.ciperchile.cl/2026/07/10/patrimonio-arqueologico-bajo-amenaza-por-la-megarreforma-la-falsa-eficiencia-de-destruir-antes-de-conocer/

Himley, Matthew, Aaron Malone, and Andrea Marston. 2024. “Geografías críticas de la minería y el extractivismo en América Latina.” Journal of Latin American Geography 24 (3): 23-39.

Irarrázaval, Felipe. 2025. “Permisología en perspectiva comparada.” El Mostrador, March 28.  https://www.elmostrador.cl/noticias/opinion/columnas/2025/03/28/permisologia-en-perspectiva-comparada/

Jerez, Bárbara, Ingrid Garcés, and Robinson Torres. 2021. “Lithium Extractivism and Water Injustices in the Salar de Atacama, Chile: The Colonial Shadow of Green Electromobility.” Political Geography 87: 102382.

Laborde, Antonia. 2026. “Científicos y académicos se rebelan ante el desdén de Kast hacia las ciencias sociales.” El País, August 11.  https://elpais.com/chile/2026-08-11/cientificos-y-academicos-se-rebelan-ante-el-desden-de-kast-hacia-las-ciencias-sociales.html

Méndez, Manuel, Manuel Prieto, and Milton Godoy. 2020. “Production of Subterranean Resources in the Atacama Desert: 19th and Early 20th Century Mining/Water Extraction in the Taltal District, Northern Chile.” Political Geography 81: 102194.

Miller, Katrina, and Roni Caryn Rabin. 2025. “Ban on D.E.I. Language Sweeps Through the Sciences.” New York Times, February 9. http://nytimes.com/2025/02/09/science/trump-dei-science.html

Nading, Alex M. 2020. “Living in a Toxic World.” Annual Review of Anthropology 49 (1): 209-224.

Perreault, Tom. 2013. “Dispossession by Accumulation? Mining, Water and the Nature of Enclosure on the Bolivian Altiplano.” Antipode 45 (5): 1050-1069.

Riofrancos, Thea. 2025. Extraction: The Frontiers of Green Capitalism. New York: W. W. Norton.

Schuessler, Jennifer. 2026. “DOGE’s Termination of Humanities Grants Is Ruled Unconstitutional.” New York Times, May 7. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/07/arts/neh-grants-lawsuit-doge.html

Schwabish, Jonathan, and Judah Axelrod. 2025. “NSF Has Canceled More Than 1,500 Grants. Nearly 90 Percent Were Related to DEI.” Urban Institute, July 9. https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/nsf-has-canceled-more-1500-grants-nearly-90-percent-were-related-dei?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Stoler, Ann Laura. 2008. “Imperial Debris: Reflections on Ruins and Ruination.” Cultural Anthropology 23 (2): 191-219.

Weinberg, Marina, and Valentina Figueroa. 2023. “Politics of Mining: Toxic Heritage in the Atacama Desert.” In Toxic Heritage: Legacies, Futures, and Environmental Justice, edited by Elizabeth Kryder-Reid and Sarah May, 109-124. New York: Routledge.