Introduction
Reproduction and sexuality have long been a central axis of political dispute. Yet today, a deteriorating environment, the increasing precarization of life, and the multiple conflicts taking place across the globe—amid the rise of authoritarian regimes—bear on reproductive lives in pressing ways. In the Global North, far-right movements restrict access to reproductive healthcare while casting falling white birth rates as a demographic threat, one they attribute to migration from the Global South and to higher fertility of racialized migrant populations. Reproduction thus becomes a terrain for defending white national identities against an imagined “replacement.” Latin America is no bystander. Decades of feminist, LGBTQ+, and human rights struggles have won significant legal victories in the region, most recently those of the marea verde. These gains are now threatened by the consolidation of authoritarian and far-right regimes across the region in alliance with increasingly strengthened and emboldened transnational conservative networks that are dismantling women’s institutions, gutting programs against gender-based violence, and pledging to reverse abortion rights.
In Latin America, this marks the deepening of a conservative movement closely tied to religious and political organizations that gained ground after the end of the “pink tide.” The movement promotes a patriarchal and heteronormative social order, grounded in a morality that tightly regulates sexuality considered ‘naturally’ heterosexual and saddled with its reproductive potential (Vaggione and Campos 2020). The year 2016 marked a new cycle of anti-gender mobilization (Zaremberg, Tabbush, and Friedman 2021). In Peru, under the banner Con mis hijos no te metas, some conservative Peruvians mobilized against sexual education in schools and in defense of the “natural family” (Rousseau 2020). In Colombia, religious leaders and right-wing politicians misrepresented the peace agreement with the Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias de Colombia (FARC), whose gender provisions sought to protect the rights of women and LGBTQ+ people, as a threat to the traditional family and a vehicle for “gender ideology” (Corredor 2021). This campaign helped the “No” win with 50.2% of the vote in the plebiscite and strengthened alliances between the political right and conservative religious groups (Bohórquez Oviedo 2024; Serrano Amaya 2017).
With sweeping electoral victories of the right since 2019 from Brazil, El Salvador, and Ecuador, to Argentina, Bolivia, and most recently Honduras, Costa Rica, Chile, Peru, and Colombia, this movement now finds more receptive political contexts (Pinheiro 2026). As Caminotti and Tabbush (2021) show, the frame of “gender ideology” now targets not only “doctrinal” policies that clash with religious or moral values, such as abortion, same-sex marriage, and sexual education, but also “non- doctrinal” policies that challenge patriarchal hierarchies, such as parity in political representation or violence-prevention programs. To advance these agendas, conservative actors create moral panics around "the family" and "the nation," dismantle gender equality institutions, and delegitimize feminists and women's rights defenders. Their rhetoric thrives on emotionally charged narratives about insecurity and demographic change, presenting the restoration of the “traditional family,” with its reified gender roles, as the solution to these risks (Zaremberg, Tabbush, and Friedman 2021). Peruvian President Keiko Fujimori invoked precisely such a moral panic at the UN General Assembly this September, denouncing “a cultural ideological agenda foreign to our reality,” and Chile’s response to fertility decline, discussed below, offers another example.
Yet reproduction is not only affected by anti-gender rhetoric. Reproductive lives are further undermined by interlocking social, economic, political, and environmental crises: the systematic precarization of livelihoods, growing inequality, environmental destruction, and the enduring legacies of armed conflict. Conservative projects deepen these crises. As Bello Urrego (2021) argues, Latin America's right turn has fused the defense of the "traditional family" with neoliberal and extractivist agendas, radicalizing the administration of cruelty over the cuerpos-Otros shaped by colonial hierarchies of race, class, and gender. In this sense, all politics has become reproductive politics (Briggs 2017; Roy and Thompson 2019): conservative regimes govern reproduction not only through abortion bans but through austerity, extractivism, and security policies. In this essay, we draw on our recent article in Latin American Research Review (Yopo Díaz et al. 2026) to argue that the effects of the conservative shift on reproduction and sexuality cannot be fully understood through a framework centered narrowly on individual choice. Drawing on a decade of research in Chile, Colombia, and Peru, where right-wing governments have come to power in the past six months, we use a reproductive justice lens to examine the interlocking conditions that define who may reproduce, under what conditions, and at what cost.
Beyond Choice: Reproductive Justice Framework
In Latin America, contraception and abortion have rightly been at the center of feminist struggles for reproductive autonomy. Many of these struggles have gone well beyond the language of individual choice. Colombia’s Causa Justa framed decriminalization as a matter of social justice, and acompañante networks across the region have reimagined abortion as an act of collective care (Duffy, Freeman, and Rodríguez 2023). Yet the hegemonic discourse on sexual and reproductive rights, in laws, policies, and some activist discourses, has remained largely centered on individual choice and access to services. It has overlooked the many other ways in which women’s reproductive autonomy is violated through obstetric violence, contraceptive coercion, forced sterilization, forced adoption, the absence of social protection, armed conflict, and environmental harm. How can women—and families more generally—raise children with safety and dignity under conditions of poverty, insecurity, and violence?
Reproductive justice offers a framework for naming these connections. Coined in 1994 by Black feminists in the United States, it articulates three principles: the right not to have children, the right to have children, and the right to raise them in safe, healthy, and dignified environments (Ross and Solinger 2017). Because choice is mediated by each person’s position within the social structure, its central question is not whether people can choose, but who can exercise that choice and under what conditions. Women with fewer cultural, social, and economic resources do not have the same ability to determine whether or not they want to have children and how to raise them. For women whose communities face high unemployment and poverty, and limited access to contraception and timely healthcare, abortion is rarely experienced as an act of freedom or choice (Di Chiro 2008). Black feminists documented the history of eugenic population control in the United States, including the coercion of women receiving social assistance into tubal ligation as a condition of retaining their benefits (Ross 2017). Such inequalities reveal that reproduction is stratified: social norms unevenly distribute the value of people’s lives, reproductive autonomy, and the right to (not) have children (Colen 1995).
Although coined in the United States, reproductive justice was, as Briggs (2022) recognizes, transnational since its inception, emerging through exchanges among feminists from different regions at the Cairo (1994) and Beijing (1995) conferences (Luna 2020). Following this tradition of traveling with reproductive justice, we consider it productive to place it in conversation with long-standing Latin American traditions that have linked struggles for sexual and reproductive rights with those for human rights, social justice, dignified conditions for reproduction, and the sustainability of life (Corrêa and Petchesky 1996; Reis Brandão and Da Silva Cabral 2021). We find resonances with communitarian feminisms (Cabnal 2010; Paredes 2010), decolonial feminisms (Lugones 2011), and the cuerpo-territorio perspective (Ulloa 2024), which link reproduction to coloniality, territorial dispossession, and socioeconomic inequality. Social movements have articulated similar connections. Feminist movements and community organizations such as the Enlace Continental de Mujeres Indígenas de las Américas (ECMIA) and the Centro de Culturas Indígenas del Perú (CHIRAPAQ) in Peru have mobilized the language of sexual and reproductive justice to promote access to maternal health services, comprehensive sex education, and the prevention of adolescent pregnancy and gender-based violence (ECMIA 2023). Other organizations, such as Mujeres de Zona de Sacrificio Quintero-Puchuncaví en Resistencia in Chile, do not explicitly use the grammar of reproductive justice, yet similarly tie reproductive freedom to the defense of territory and environmental justice.
This broader lens is especially important now. When reproductive politics is reduced to a binary between “choice” and “life,” conservative movements can claim the defense of family, motherhood, and life as their exclusive terrain. Yet, as the following cases from Peru, Chile, and Colombia show, their commitment to life is selective: the same regimes that restrict abortion and sexuality education and scorn gender equality also foreclose justice for reproductive violence, erode the social support for raising children, and expose communities to the violence of war and environmental harm. What distinguishes them is less a commitment to life than a commitment to punitive interventions in reproduction and sexuality (Smith 2005).
Peru: Enforcing Motherhood While Denying the Right to Parenting
In Peru, the state has harmed reproductive lives in contradictory ways, “both by enforcing motherhood or denying the right to parenting,” particularly among poor, rural, and Indigenous women (Chaparro-Buitrago and Freeman 2023, 176). Between 1996 and 2000, under Alberto Fujimori’s national family planning program, more than 270,000 women and some 22,000 men, overwhelmingly rural, poor, and Quechua-speaking, were sterilized, many without informed consent (Boesten 2007; Chaparro-Buitrago 2022). Presented as a reproductive health policy, the program promised to make women “the masters of their own destiny” (Chaparro-Buitrago 2019). In practice, the campaign was a eugenic project of population control that subjected peasant and Indigenous women’s lives to “the logic of economic rationality, bundled up with the eugenic legacy to calculate who deserves to be born and who does not” (Chaparro-Buitrago 2022, 307). Survivors describe the harm less as infertility than as a loss of strength that undermined their capacity to work, strained their families, and isolated them in their communities. These “debilitated lifeworlds” encompass a constellation of embodied, emotional, social, and family harms that a reproductive rights framework, focused almost exclusively on the loss of fertility, cannot grasp (Chaparro-Buitrago 2022).
Meanwhile, the same state criminalizes abortion and enforces compulsory motherhood. Abortion is punishable by up to two years in prison for the woman and up to five for the provider. Although therapeutic abortion has been legal since 1924, no protocol governed its provision until 2014 (Ministerio de Salud 2014), and access remains severely restricted. An estimated 350,000 clandestine abortions take place each year (Cáceres et al. 2008), and the enforcement of motherhood rests on routine criminalization. Between 2012 and 2022, the Public Prosecutor's Office registered 12,859 abortion cases, including 21 for therapeutic abortion, despite its legality (Justicia Verde 2025). Criminalization begins in the same hospitals where women seek care, even for those treated for pregnancy loss (Salazar 2019). Justicia Verde (2025) found that four in five prosecutions start there, most often reported by the health care staff who treated the woman. Prosecutions follow racialized patterns that echo those of forced sterilization: regions with larger Quechua-speaking populations register far higher rates of prosecution, with Ayacucho recording more than eight times as many complaints as Callao. These patterns suggest that groups of women once targeted by state sterilization programs now bear a disproportionate burden of prosecution for ending a pregnancy.
The conservative turn has deepened both forms of harm. For survivors of the sterilizations, it has narrowed the path to justice. In August 2024, Congress approved Law 32107, which restricts crimes against humanity and war crimes to acts committed after 2002, subjecting earlier crimes, including those of the armed conflict (1980-2000) and the Fujimori years, to the statute of limitations of the 1991 Penal Code (OMCT 2025). As a result, crimes such as forced sterilizations can now expire*. Days later, a court annulled the criminal accusation against Alberto Fujimori for the sterilizations on procedural grounds. However, impunity has not gone unchallenged. In March 2026, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights held Peru responsible in Celia Ramos Durand v. Peru, and a chamber of the Supreme Court declined to apply Law 32107 in a sterilization case, invoking Peru’s international obligations (Casimiro 2026). Yet, with the Constitutional Court having upheld the law, each case now depends on individual judges willing to set it aside. The legal architecture of impunity thus makes justice harder to reach.
On the other side of the ledger, the enforcement of motherhood has become increasingly aggressive, even against girls who are victims of rape. In February 2026, Milagros Jáuregui, congresswoman, evangelical pastor, and then Rafael Lopez Aliaga’s running mate for Renovación Popular—who now backs Fujimori’s government—boasted that girls aged 10 to 13 who had been raped underwent “emotional healing” at her shelter, Casa del Padre. The girls carried their pregnancies to term instead of accessing legal therapeutic abortion. Jáuregui now sits in the Senate. The state’s neglect is further revealed in its treatment of Indigenous girls. In 2024, the Ministry of Education revealed that 524 teachers had been accused of sexually abusing Awajún children in Condorcanqui (Amazonas) since 2010, yet only 111 had been dismissed. Rather than guaranteeing protection, both the current and previous governments have framed the abuse as based on “cultural practices” (Guadarmino 2024; Huaita 2026). In August 2026, a Renovación Popular deputy requested the confidential medical records of a woman seeking a therapeutic abortion at the regional hospital in Abancay. Legal experts denounced the request as a violation of medical confidentiality. This was the same hospital where, in 2017, a 13-year-old named Camila was denied timely access to a therapeutic abortion, a case the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child found violated Peru’s international obligations (OHCHR 2023).
Chile: Fueling Pronatalism Amidst Neoliberal Austerity
Neoliberal restructuring in Latin America, marked by the erosion of social security, the subsidiarity of public policies, the depoliticization of civil society, and the individualization or risk and insecurity, has commodified and precarized life (Gago 2015). Chile, a paradigmatic case of neoliberal restructuring, reveals the dramatic aftermath of these structural transformations on reproductive rights and social justice with particular clarity.
Chile has one of the highest cesarean section rates in the world. In 2021, cesarean sections accounted for 59 percent of births in the country, a figure that reached 62 percent in the private healthcare system (Sadler and Leiva 2023), far exceeding the 10 to 15 percent recommended by the World Health Organization (2015). This excess cannot be understood independently from the privatization of the healthcare system and the implementation of a neoliberal model. An exploitative economic logic has permeated childbirth to such an extent that some medical professionals describe vaginal births as causing “economic harm” (Sadler and Leiva 2023). This commodification of childbirth shows how criteria of time efficiency and profit can constrain mothers’ autonomy over childbirth and increase their vulnerability to obstetric violence.
The erosion of social security and the privatization of care have also made it increasingly difficult to have children at all, pushing women to delay the transition to motherhood. The proportion of women who become mothers after thirty increased from 12.9 percent in 2008 to 23.6 percent in 2018 (Yopo Díaz 2023). Although postponing motherhood is often interpreted as a sign of greater reproductive autonomy, it cannot be understood apart from the increasing precarization of the social conditions for having and raising children. Women contemplating motherhood worry about how they will pay for a good school, hospital bills, or rent in a safe neighborhood (Yopo Díaz 2021). Postponement thus forms part of the repertoire of strategies that Latin American women deploy to protect their children and safeguard their families amid poverty, insecurity, and violence (Zubillaga et al. 2019). Consequently, this postponement reflects growing constraints on women’s ability to decide whether to have children and on their capacity to raise them in dignified, safe, and sustainable environments. Furthermore, as childcare costs rise, having children is increasingly becoming a class privilege, and only a few can afford to have the families they want (Yopo Díaz 2025). What is at stake, then, is not only individual choice but the collective conditions for the sustainability of life.
As the right to have children and to parent in safe and dignified conditions continues to be undermined by neoliberalism and precarity, pronatalism has strongly resurged. In 2025, Chile’s Total Fertility Rate (TFR) fell to only 0.99 children per woman, the lowest in its history and one of the lowest in the world (INE 2026). A society long concerned with adolescent pregnancy and large families has brought a new anxiety to the fore: the declining number of births. The new conservative government has put this “silent crisis” at the center of its agenda. In his first annual address in June 2026, President Kast launched the Plan Chile Renace—which was also one of his campaign’s promises—attributing many of the country’s problems to “the weakening of the family.” Yet the same government promised to cut US$6 billion in public spending in 16 months, further eroding social security and hindering families from having and raising children. Nor does this pronatalism value all births equally. In 2022, 18.9% of births nationwide were to migrant mothers, rising as high as 47.9% in northern regions such as Tarapacá (INE 2025). Echoing concerns in the Global North, growing alarm about migrant fertility fuels reproductive nationalism and demographic anxieties about the nation’s future. The result is a cruel and vivid representation of selective pronatalism that assigns uneven worth to fertility and human life according to nationality, ethnicity, and race.
Colombia: Reproduction During Armed Conflict and Environmental Violence
In Colombia, reproductive violence cannot be separated from the armed conflict and territorial dispossession. Over six decades, guerrillas, paramilitaries, and state forces committed sexual violence against more than 37,000 officially registered victims, most of them Afro-Colombian, Indigenous, and peasant women and girls (Dávila et al. 2019). Women’s bodies were treated as appropriable resources of the land. Many became pregnant and for reasons including lack of access to abortion, gave birth to children who, in some communities, were labelled after their perpetrators, as paraquitos (“little para militaries”) (Sánchez Parra 2024). Within rebel groups, reproduction was also governed by force. As local human rights organizations and courts have now recognized, women combatants were subjected to other forms of reproductive injustice: forced contraception and abortions (Center for Reproductive Rights 2020). Forced motherhood and coerced abortions, two sides of the same violence, thus remain one of the war’s least visible harms.
War’s effects on reproduction are also intrinsically linked to environmental devastation. The armed conflict fostered collaboration between economic actors and armed groups, many of which instilled fear to clear the way for large-scale extractive projects (Comisión de la Verdad 2022, 166). Environmental degradation also came from the state through aerial spraying with glyphosate, which became the centerpiece of the state’s counternarcotics policy from the early 2000s. For those living near coca fields or working as growers and harvesters, military planes spraying this toxic herbicide were a source of terror as it destroyed the livelihoods of peasant families with no other means of subsistence. As one campesino leader recalled: “They left the land barren… There are no crops… It’s good for nothing: not even straw grows” (Comisión de la Verdad 2022, 173).
This interconnected depletion of land, livelihoods, and reproductive capacities can be understood through the concept of reproductive extractivism (Chaparro-Buitrago 2025). The cuerpo-territorio perspective further illuminates this entanglement: when territories are poisoned, so too are the bodies that inhabit them (Ulloa 2024). Glyphosate has been associated with effects on fertility, miscarriage, and perinatal health (Center for Reproductive Rights 2020). Yet miscarriages linked to spraying remain largely unrecognized; only two cases have been accepted in court, and health institutions routinely dismiss women’s symptoms and bodily knowledge (Chiavaroli 2024b). Denied recognition, these women are recast as “faulty mothers,” blamed for failing to protect pregnancies the state itself contaminated (Chiavaroli 2024a).
Transitional justice has begun to challenge this invisibility. Colombia’s Comisión de la Verdad, the first truth-seeking body in the world to investigate reproductive violence, identified aerial spraying as a form of conflict-related reproductive harm, and recommended the state to stop using glyphosate (Sánchez Parra 2023). In addition, the Jurisdicción Especial para la Paz opened a macro-case on sexual and reproductive violence in 2023. However, the recent conservative turn is now dismantling these advances. In August 2026, three weeks after taking office, Abelardo de la Espriella’s government revoked Resolution 006 of 2015 of the Consejo Nacional de Estupefacientes (National Narcotics Council) that had suspended aerial spraying with glyphosate. Soon after, the government authorized a pilot program in the Putumayo region for aerial spraying with glufosinate-ammonium, an herbicide whose authorization the European Union did not renew—in part because it’s classified as toxic for reproduction—and which the World Health Organization places in a higher acute toxicity hazard category than glyphosate (Sánchez Martínez 2026, WHO 2020).
The new government has also embraced a batalla cultural or “culture battle” in defense of the traditional family and Christian values, a linchpin of the transnational far right. This battle extends to historical memory, the armed conflict, and national identity (Neira 2026). Salvación Nacional, the party backing the government, and the Partido Conservador Colombiano have expressed support for a bill seeking to ban abortion; an initiative that would reverse the Constitutional Court’s 2022 decriminalization up to 24 weeks (Vanegas 2026). Similarly, the head of the Instituto Colombiano de Bienestar Familiar (ICBF), the agency responsible for child protection, adoptions, and family welfare, recently announced in Congress that definitions of family will change “because the family is one, not families,” an assertion widely read as excluding single-parent, extended, LGBTQ+, and other families that do not fit the nuclear model (Bernal 2026).
Conclusion
In this essay, we discussed Peru, Chile, and Colombia to show how interlocking economic, political, and environmental crises undermine reproductive autonomy in the region, and how the conservative turn simultaneously deepens these harms on several fronts. In Peru, the state governs reproduction in contradictory ways, narrowing paths to justice for survivors of forced sterilization while criminalizing abortion and forcing victims of rape into motherhood. In Chile, a government promotes pronatalism while cutting the public supports that make it possible to have and raise children and casts migrant fertility as a threat to the nation. In Colombia, a government committed to a cultural battle in defense of the traditional family seeks to restrict abortion while reviving aerial spraying, a policy that has harmed the land, peasant livelihoods, and the reproductive bodies of rural women. Across these contexts, a selective commitment to the “family” and “life” is instrumentalized by the conservative backlash while governments deepen reproductive injustice through impunity, austerity, extractivism, and militarized security.
A framework centered narrowly on individual choice cannot capture how reproduction is governed in the region. Reproduction is a terrain on which social and historical struggles play out, and reproductive justice makes these connections visible. By holding together the right not to have children, the right to have them, and the right to raise them in safe and dignified conditions, it reveals how states and those in power enforce motherhood on some women while denying it to others, and how conditions for sustaining life are eroded even by those who claim to defend it. This encompassing framework does not simply travel from North to South, rather, it connects to Latin American epistemological traditions and social movements that have long linked reproductive rights to human rights, social justice, and the sustainability of life.
In the face of the right’s electoral wins across the region, reproductive justice helps us address a central challenge: how to defend the right to have children without turning motherhood into an obligation. As Chile’s pronatalist turn shows, this right can easily be captured by discourses that treat women’s reproductive capacities as serving the family, the nation, or demographic goals, and that value some births more than others according to class, race, and nationality. Although reproductive justice can reinforce repronormative mandates when mobilized uncritically (Chaparro-Buitrago and Freeman 2023), its strength lies in its capacity to overcome the apparent contradiction between reproductive autonomy and the decision to have children. It allows us to defend the right of all people to have, or not to have, the families they want, precisely because it refuses to separate the right to have children from the right not to have them. This expansive understanding of reproductive freedom requires both freedom from coercion and securing the material conditions that make reproductive decisions possible and achievable: healthcare, social protection, clean environments, and freedom from violence and oppression, all of which depend on confronting the social inequalities that stratify reproduction.
Reproductive justice also offers us a political strategy. Conservative movements in Latin America and beyond have not only appropriated the language of family, motherhood, and life; they have built a comprehensive political platform that ties gender, sexuality, and the family to the nation, security, and “economic freedom.” Thompson (2017) observes how the radical right in the United States forged such a multi-issue agenda while the pro-choice movement avoided multi-issue alliances for fear of diluting its focus on abortion. Yet, as she notes, “backpedaling and compromising has not contributed to a strengthened pro-choice movement or the security of abortion rights” (Thompson 2017, 284). Rejecting single-issue politics shatters the binary of pro-choice versus pro-life and challenges conservative actors’ instrumental use of family and life (Smith 2005). By situating reproduction within a broader social justice agenda, it enables coalition-building among feminist, Indigenous, environmental, disability, labor and victim families’ movements around shared struggles against the socioeconomic processes that threaten social reproduction (Di Chiro 2008; Stote 2017). Many Latin American movements already practice this politics, from communitarian feminists denouncing the poisoning of their land and bodies to survivors demanding justice for forced sterilization (see Chaparro-Buitrago 2025). At a moment when authoritarian projects claim to speak for life and family, strengthening these alliances around this comprehensive political platform is more urgent than ever if we are to imagine futures that truly sustain life for all.